Under what circumstance is a batter not called out after a dropped third strike?

In baseball, a dropped third strike rule creates specific scenarios where a batter can remain safe rather than being called out. When analyzing the varied conditions, it is important to recognize that all the provided scenarios uphold the premise of the batter potentially not being called out.

When there are fewer than two outs, the batter can attempt to reach first base if a third strike is dropped. This situation allows for an opportunity to run, making it advantageous for the batter should they choose to capitalize on the catcher’s inability to secure the ball.

If the batter is already running to first base after the dropped third strike, they maintain their eligibility to reach the base safely. This movement shows an intent to advance, and as long as they follow the rules regarding the play, they are not regarded as out.

Lastly, if the pitch hits the ground before reaching the catcher, it is considered a dropped third strike and allows the batter to go to first base despite the catcher's failure to secure the ball. This circumstance inherently provides the batter with the opportunity to run freely to first base, ultimately preventing an out call.

Considering all these elements, it stands clear that any of these conditions allows the batter to avoid being called out after a dropped third strike, encapsulating the reasoning behind